Is there an online compendium of Rav Moshe teshuvos in English that exists?Parashat Tazria+HachodeshPesach/PassoverWhich sections of Igros Moshe are in which volumes?Who asked Rav Moshe about capital punishment?Online English Rashi (Talmud)Rav Moshe milk and tunaRav Moshe Feinstein and tzitzis tucked inRav Moshe on mechitzah and kalus roshRav Moshe Feinstein and showers in the nine daysRav Ovadia Yosef's Books OnlineIs there an online list of English sefarim?Is there a topic index for Igrot Moshe?Is there an English Shulchan Aruch Audio online?

DC-DC converter from low voltage at high current, to high voltage at low current

Approximately how much travel time was saved by the opening of the Suez Canal in 1869?

Revoked SSL certificate

Does detail obscure or enhance action?

Today is the Center

How much of data wrangling is a data scientist's job?

Is it legal for company to use my work email to pretend I still work there?

Roll the carpet

Can I make popcorn with any corn?

meaning of に in 本当に?

Why can't I see bouncing of switch on oscilloscope screen?

Watching something be written to a file live with tail

How to format long polynomial?

Why do I get two different answers for this counting problem?

Do infinite dimensional systems make sense?

Do I have a twin with permutated remainders?

Two films in a tank, only one comes out with a development error – why?

Which country benefited the most from UN Security Council vetoes?

Why is Minecraft giving an OpenGL error?

Cross compiling for RPi - error while loading shared libraries

What does "Puller Prush Person" mean?

What's the output of a record needle playing an out-of-speed record

RSA: Danger of using p to create q

dbcc cleantable batch size explanation



Is there an online compendium of Rav Moshe teshuvos in English that exists?



Parashat Tazria+Hachodesh
Pesach/PassoverWhich sections of Igros Moshe are in which volumes?Who asked Rav Moshe about capital punishment?Online English Rashi (Talmud)Rav Moshe milk and tunaRav Moshe Feinstein and tzitzis tucked inRav Moshe on mechitzah and kalus roshRav Moshe Feinstein and showers in the nine daysRav Ovadia Yosef's Books OnlineIs there an online list of English sefarim?Is there a topic index for Igrot Moshe?Is there an English Shulchan Aruch Audio online?










3















I see and hear lots of Rav Moshe's teshuvos quoted, mostly the "famous" ones.



For example, a number of notable Rav Moshe teshuvos can be found on Rav Moshe's Wikipedia page:



enter image description hereenter image description here



Does an English online compendium that collects (many/most/all) of Rav Moshe teshuvos exist?










share|improve this question



















  • 2





    IINM he didn't let people translate his writings

    – Double AA
    Apr 2 at 23:03






  • 5





    @DoubleAA Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:21






  • 5





    And Y.D. 4:38

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:23






  • 1





    Why'd this get a downvote?

    – user6591
    2 days ago






  • 1





    re: index, see here, re translations in English I don't believe they exist as RMF was opposed to them. Bits and pieces were translated in specific works, e.g., on his opinions re cardiac vs. brain death

    – mbloch
    2 days ago















3















I see and hear lots of Rav Moshe's teshuvos quoted, mostly the "famous" ones.



For example, a number of notable Rav Moshe teshuvos can be found on Rav Moshe's Wikipedia page:



enter image description hereenter image description here



Does an English online compendium that collects (many/most/all) of Rav Moshe teshuvos exist?










share|improve this question



















  • 2





    IINM he didn't let people translate his writings

    – Double AA
    Apr 2 at 23:03






  • 5





    @DoubleAA Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:21






  • 5





    And Y.D. 4:38

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:23






  • 1





    Why'd this get a downvote?

    – user6591
    2 days ago






  • 1





    re: index, see here, re translations in English I don't believe they exist as RMF was opposed to them. Bits and pieces were translated in specific works, e.g., on his opinions re cardiac vs. brain death

    – mbloch
    2 days ago













3












3








3








I see and hear lots of Rav Moshe's teshuvos quoted, mostly the "famous" ones.



For example, a number of notable Rav Moshe teshuvos can be found on Rav Moshe's Wikipedia page:



enter image description hereenter image description here



Does an English online compendium that collects (many/most/all) of Rav Moshe teshuvos exist?










share|improve this question
















I see and hear lots of Rav Moshe's teshuvos quoted, mostly the "famous" ones.



For example, a number of notable Rav Moshe teshuvos can be found on Rav Moshe's Wikipedia page:



enter image description hereenter image description here



Does an English online compendium that collects (many/most/all) of Rav Moshe teshuvos exist?







product-recommendation moshe-feinstein






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 2 days ago









Al Berko

6,4201529




6,4201529










asked Apr 2 at 22:53









alichtalicht

2,6871633




2,6871633







  • 2





    IINM he didn't let people translate his writings

    – Double AA
    Apr 2 at 23:03






  • 5





    @DoubleAA Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:21






  • 5





    And Y.D. 4:38

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:23






  • 1





    Why'd this get a downvote?

    – user6591
    2 days ago






  • 1





    re: index, see here, re translations in English I don't believe they exist as RMF was opposed to them. Bits and pieces were translated in specific works, e.g., on his opinions re cardiac vs. brain death

    – mbloch
    2 days ago












  • 2





    IINM he didn't let people translate his writings

    – Double AA
    Apr 2 at 23:03






  • 5





    @DoubleAA Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:21






  • 5





    And Y.D. 4:38

    – Alex
    Apr 2 at 23:23






  • 1





    Why'd this get a downvote?

    – user6591
    2 days ago






  • 1





    re: index, see here, re translations in English I don't believe they exist as RMF was opposed to them. Bits and pieces were translated in specific works, e.g., on his opinions re cardiac vs. brain death

    – mbloch
    2 days ago







2




2





IINM he didn't let people translate his writings

– Double AA
Apr 2 at 23:03





IINM he didn't let people translate his writings

– Double AA
Apr 2 at 23:03




5




5





@DoubleAA Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91

– Alex
Apr 2 at 23:21





@DoubleAA Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91

– Alex
Apr 2 at 23:21




5




5





And Y.D. 4:38

– Alex
Apr 2 at 23:23





And Y.D. 4:38

– Alex
Apr 2 at 23:23




1




1





Why'd this get a downvote?

– user6591
2 days ago





Why'd this get a downvote?

– user6591
2 days ago




1




1





re: index, see here, re translations in English I don't believe they exist as RMF was opposed to them. Bits and pieces were translated in specific works, e.g., on his opinions re cardiac vs. brain death

– mbloch
2 days ago





re: index, see here, re translations in English I don't believe they exist as RMF was opposed to them. Bits and pieces were translated in specific works, e.g., on his opinions re cardiac vs. brain death

– mbloch
2 days ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















8














As noted in the comments by several Mi Yodeyans1, the lack of a compendium/ collection of Rav Moshe's teshuvos translated to English is no coincidence: it's what Rav Moshe himself wanted.



Rav Moshe didn't want his teshuvos translated to English for fear that people would erroneously draw comparisons from his teshuvos and incorrectly apply his psakim.



As Rav Moshe writes Y.D. 4:38:




איסור לפרסם קיצורי דינים ופסקים מספרי תשובות וגם לתרגם תשובות ללשון המדינה



אף שאני כותב עתה תשובה ארוכה בדבר השמות אבל מכתבי זה הוא בקיצור בדבר ששמעתי שאחד עשה ספר בלע״ז בהעתקת דינים מהספר אגרות משה שלי, והוא איסור אף אם היה התרגום ראוי שבזמננו ליכא מי שיכול לומר ולהדפיס פסקים בלא באור ומקורות, וכבר בקש ממני רשות איזה אינשי מכאן ואמרתי שאיני נותן רשות על זה. וגם נמצא שלא העתיק כראוי ויש כמה דברים בטעותים וכמה דברים שגורמים לטעות שזה עוד גרוע ביותר, וגם להעתיק התשובות ממש פשוט שהוא חסרון גדול ליתן הפסקים לאינשי דעלמא שאינם ת״ח שיבואו לדמות מלתא למלתא ולכן אני מוחה בכל תוקף שיש למחות.



It is forbidden to publish abbreviations and rulings from responsa and to translate answers to the language of the state



... I heard that one of them had done a book in the Hebrew language in copying laws from the my sefer Igrot Moshe, which is prohibited even if the translation was appropriate [...] a number of people asked me for permission [to translate Igrot Moshe into English] and I told them I did not give permission for this.




Rav Moshe also addresses this in Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91.



Note: only translated small portions of the teshuva since it would be not only ironic but wrong to go against Rav Moshe's wishes in the exact teshuva where he writes he doesn't want Igrot Moshe to be translated



(hopefully the 2 snippets I translated were ok- in as much as they can help teach and serve as a disclaimer to what Rav Moshe's preferences in this matter are)



1 @DoubleAA, @mbloch, @Alex thanks also for the 2 Igrot Moshe teshuvot referenced.






share|improve this answer
































    5














    R. Feinstein's son in law R. Moshe Dovid Tendler published a translation/commentary of some of R. Feinstein's responsa relating to medical issues. The book is called Responsa of Rav Moshe Feinstein: Translation and Commentary Vol I Care of the Critically Ill. In his introduction R. Tendler discusses R. Feinsteins responsum (Y.D. 3:91) that prohibited the translation of his responsa, and R. Tendler cites a later responsum (Y.D. 4:38) to explain why his translation is okay. He also adds:




    My great father-in-law, זצ"ל, in discussions at my home, where for decades he spent the Succos holy days, further elaborated on this point. He asked me to translate those responsa which I felt it was important for our brethren to understand, but to do so "as a rebbe teaches a talmid." He asked that I work with meticulous care, presenting all the relevant background material in a lucid style, with full awareness that the readership would span the spectrum from Torah scholars to people with minimal background. He added, as an aside, that an English translation of the responsa would be available to non-Jews as well. Although teaching Torah to non-Jews is prohibited, our purpose in translating these responsa is to instruct Jews, and therefore we need not consider this translation a violation of the edict concerning the study of Torah by non-Jews.



    I have prepared the following translations in accordance with the above instructions. Although the English version is faithful to the original, I have included additional material, enclosed in brackets, to instruct and edify those who will turn to the writings of the greatest posek of our generation as to a personal rebbe.




    Portions of this book are available online at Google Books, and it is available on Sefaria as well.




    In Theology in the Responsa R. Louis Jacobs goes through each century of responsa literature and summarizes those responsa that relate to theology. In the section for the twentieth century he summarizes three of R. Feinstein's responsa. However, as far as I know this cannot be read online.






    share|improve this answer






























      2 Answers
      2






      active

      oldest

      votes








      2 Answers
      2






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes









      8














      As noted in the comments by several Mi Yodeyans1, the lack of a compendium/ collection of Rav Moshe's teshuvos translated to English is no coincidence: it's what Rav Moshe himself wanted.



      Rav Moshe didn't want his teshuvos translated to English for fear that people would erroneously draw comparisons from his teshuvos and incorrectly apply his psakim.



      As Rav Moshe writes Y.D. 4:38:




      איסור לפרסם קיצורי דינים ופסקים מספרי תשובות וגם לתרגם תשובות ללשון המדינה



      אף שאני כותב עתה תשובה ארוכה בדבר השמות אבל מכתבי זה הוא בקיצור בדבר ששמעתי שאחד עשה ספר בלע״ז בהעתקת דינים מהספר אגרות משה שלי, והוא איסור אף אם היה התרגום ראוי שבזמננו ליכא מי שיכול לומר ולהדפיס פסקים בלא באור ומקורות, וכבר בקש ממני רשות איזה אינשי מכאן ואמרתי שאיני נותן רשות על זה. וגם נמצא שלא העתיק כראוי ויש כמה דברים בטעותים וכמה דברים שגורמים לטעות שזה עוד גרוע ביותר, וגם להעתיק התשובות ממש פשוט שהוא חסרון גדול ליתן הפסקים לאינשי דעלמא שאינם ת״ח שיבואו לדמות מלתא למלתא ולכן אני מוחה בכל תוקף שיש למחות.



      It is forbidden to publish abbreviations and rulings from responsa and to translate answers to the language of the state



      ... I heard that one of them had done a book in the Hebrew language in copying laws from the my sefer Igrot Moshe, which is prohibited even if the translation was appropriate [...] a number of people asked me for permission [to translate Igrot Moshe into English] and I told them I did not give permission for this.




      Rav Moshe also addresses this in Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91.



      Note: only translated small portions of the teshuva since it would be not only ironic but wrong to go against Rav Moshe's wishes in the exact teshuva where he writes he doesn't want Igrot Moshe to be translated



      (hopefully the 2 snippets I translated were ok- in as much as they can help teach and serve as a disclaimer to what Rav Moshe's preferences in this matter are)



      1 @DoubleAA, @mbloch, @Alex thanks also for the 2 Igrot Moshe teshuvot referenced.






      share|improve this answer





























        8














        As noted in the comments by several Mi Yodeyans1, the lack of a compendium/ collection of Rav Moshe's teshuvos translated to English is no coincidence: it's what Rav Moshe himself wanted.



        Rav Moshe didn't want his teshuvos translated to English for fear that people would erroneously draw comparisons from his teshuvos and incorrectly apply his psakim.



        As Rav Moshe writes Y.D. 4:38:




        איסור לפרסם קיצורי דינים ופסקים מספרי תשובות וגם לתרגם תשובות ללשון המדינה



        אף שאני כותב עתה תשובה ארוכה בדבר השמות אבל מכתבי זה הוא בקיצור בדבר ששמעתי שאחד עשה ספר בלע״ז בהעתקת דינים מהספר אגרות משה שלי, והוא איסור אף אם היה התרגום ראוי שבזמננו ליכא מי שיכול לומר ולהדפיס פסקים בלא באור ומקורות, וכבר בקש ממני רשות איזה אינשי מכאן ואמרתי שאיני נותן רשות על זה. וגם נמצא שלא העתיק כראוי ויש כמה דברים בטעותים וכמה דברים שגורמים לטעות שזה עוד גרוע ביותר, וגם להעתיק התשובות ממש פשוט שהוא חסרון גדול ליתן הפסקים לאינשי דעלמא שאינם ת״ח שיבואו לדמות מלתא למלתא ולכן אני מוחה בכל תוקף שיש למחות.



        It is forbidden to publish abbreviations and rulings from responsa and to translate answers to the language of the state



        ... I heard that one of them had done a book in the Hebrew language in copying laws from the my sefer Igrot Moshe, which is prohibited even if the translation was appropriate [...] a number of people asked me for permission [to translate Igrot Moshe into English] and I told them I did not give permission for this.




        Rav Moshe also addresses this in Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91.



        Note: only translated small portions of the teshuva since it would be not only ironic but wrong to go against Rav Moshe's wishes in the exact teshuva where he writes he doesn't want Igrot Moshe to be translated



        (hopefully the 2 snippets I translated were ok- in as much as they can help teach and serve as a disclaimer to what Rav Moshe's preferences in this matter are)



        1 @DoubleAA, @mbloch, @Alex thanks also for the 2 Igrot Moshe teshuvot referenced.






        share|improve this answer



























          8












          8








          8







          As noted in the comments by several Mi Yodeyans1, the lack of a compendium/ collection of Rav Moshe's teshuvos translated to English is no coincidence: it's what Rav Moshe himself wanted.



          Rav Moshe didn't want his teshuvos translated to English for fear that people would erroneously draw comparisons from his teshuvos and incorrectly apply his psakim.



          As Rav Moshe writes Y.D. 4:38:




          איסור לפרסם קיצורי דינים ופסקים מספרי תשובות וגם לתרגם תשובות ללשון המדינה



          אף שאני כותב עתה תשובה ארוכה בדבר השמות אבל מכתבי זה הוא בקיצור בדבר ששמעתי שאחד עשה ספר בלע״ז בהעתקת דינים מהספר אגרות משה שלי, והוא איסור אף אם היה התרגום ראוי שבזמננו ליכא מי שיכול לומר ולהדפיס פסקים בלא באור ומקורות, וכבר בקש ממני רשות איזה אינשי מכאן ואמרתי שאיני נותן רשות על זה. וגם נמצא שלא העתיק כראוי ויש כמה דברים בטעותים וכמה דברים שגורמים לטעות שזה עוד גרוע ביותר, וגם להעתיק התשובות ממש פשוט שהוא חסרון גדול ליתן הפסקים לאינשי דעלמא שאינם ת״ח שיבואו לדמות מלתא למלתא ולכן אני מוחה בכל תוקף שיש למחות.



          It is forbidden to publish abbreviations and rulings from responsa and to translate answers to the language of the state



          ... I heard that one of them had done a book in the Hebrew language in copying laws from the my sefer Igrot Moshe, which is prohibited even if the translation was appropriate [...] a number of people asked me for permission [to translate Igrot Moshe into English] and I told them I did not give permission for this.




          Rav Moshe also addresses this in Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91.



          Note: only translated small portions of the teshuva since it would be not only ironic but wrong to go against Rav Moshe's wishes in the exact teshuva where he writes he doesn't want Igrot Moshe to be translated



          (hopefully the 2 snippets I translated were ok- in as much as they can help teach and serve as a disclaimer to what Rav Moshe's preferences in this matter are)



          1 @DoubleAA, @mbloch, @Alex thanks also for the 2 Igrot Moshe teshuvot referenced.






          share|improve this answer















          As noted in the comments by several Mi Yodeyans1, the lack of a compendium/ collection of Rav Moshe's teshuvos translated to English is no coincidence: it's what Rav Moshe himself wanted.



          Rav Moshe didn't want his teshuvos translated to English for fear that people would erroneously draw comparisons from his teshuvos and incorrectly apply his psakim.



          As Rav Moshe writes Y.D. 4:38:




          איסור לפרסם קיצורי דינים ופסקים מספרי תשובות וגם לתרגם תשובות ללשון המדינה



          אף שאני כותב עתה תשובה ארוכה בדבר השמות אבל מכתבי זה הוא בקיצור בדבר ששמעתי שאחד עשה ספר בלע״ז בהעתקת דינים מהספר אגרות משה שלי, והוא איסור אף אם היה התרגום ראוי שבזמננו ליכא מי שיכול לומר ולהדפיס פסקים בלא באור ומקורות, וכבר בקש ממני רשות איזה אינשי מכאן ואמרתי שאיני נותן רשות על זה. וגם נמצא שלא העתיק כראוי ויש כמה דברים בטעותים וכמה דברים שגורמים לטעות שזה עוד גרוע ביותר, וגם להעתיק התשובות ממש פשוט שהוא חסרון גדול ליתן הפסקים לאינשי דעלמא שאינם ת״ח שיבואו לדמות מלתא למלתא ולכן אני מוחה בכל תוקף שיש למחות.



          It is forbidden to publish abbreviations and rulings from responsa and to translate answers to the language of the state



          ... I heard that one of them had done a book in the Hebrew language in copying laws from the my sefer Igrot Moshe, which is prohibited even if the translation was appropriate [...] a number of people asked me for permission [to translate Igrot Moshe into English] and I told them I did not give permission for this.




          Rav Moshe also addresses this in Igrot Moshe Y.D. 3:91.



          Note: only translated small portions of the teshuva since it would be not only ironic but wrong to go against Rav Moshe's wishes in the exact teshuva where he writes he doesn't want Igrot Moshe to be translated



          (hopefully the 2 snippets I translated were ok- in as much as they can help teach and serve as a disclaimer to what Rav Moshe's preferences in this matter are)



          1 @DoubleAA, @mbloch, @Alex thanks also for the 2 Igrot Moshe teshuvot referenced.







          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited 2 days ago

























          answered 2 days ago









          alichtalicht

          2,6871633




          2,6871633





















              5














              R. Feinstein's son in law R. Moshe Dovid Tendler published a translation/commentary of some of R. Feinstein's responsa relating to medical issues. The book is called Responsa of Rav Moshe Feinstein: Translation and Commentary Vol I Care of the Critically Ill. In his introduction R. Tendler discusses R. Feinsteins responsum (Y.D. 3:91) that prohibited the translation of his responsa, and R. Tendler cites a later responsum (Y.D. 4:38) to explain why his translation is okay. He also adds:




              My great father-in-law, זצ"ל, in discussions at my home, where for decades he spent the Succos holy days, further elaborated on this point. He asked me to translate those responsa which I felt it was important for our brethren to understand, but to do so "as a rebbe teaches a talmid." He asked that I work with meticulous care, presenting all the relevant background material in a lucid style, with full awareness that the readership would span the spectrum from Torah scholars to people with minimal background. He added, as an aside, that an English translation of the responsa would be available to non-Jews as well. Although teaching Torah to non-Jews is prohibited, our purpose in translating these responsa is to instruct Jews, and therefore we need not consider this translation a violation of the edict concerning the study of Torah by non-Jews.



              I have prepared the following translations in accordance with the above instructions. Although the English version is faithful to the original, I have included additional material, enclosed in brackets, to instruct and edify those who will turn to the writings of the greatest posek of our generation as to a personal rebbe.




              Portions of this book are available online at Google Books, and it is available on Sefaria as well.




              In Theology in the Responsa R. Louis Jacobs goes through each century of responsa literature and summarizes those responsa that relate to theology. In the section for the twentieth century he summarizes three of R. Feinstein's responsa. However, as far as I know this cannot be read online.






              share|improve this answer



























                5














                R. Feinstein's son in law R. Moshe Dovid Tendler published a translation/commentary of some of R. Feinstein's responsa relating to medical issues. The book is called Responsa of Rav Moshe Feinstein: Translation and Commentary Vol I Care of the Critically Ill. In his introduction R. Tendler discusses R. Feinsteins responsum (Y.D. 3:91) that prohibited the translation of his responsa, and R. Tendler cites a later responsum (Y.D. 4:38) to explain why his translation is okay. He also adds:




                My great father-in-law, זצ"ל, in discussions at my home, where for decades he spent the Succos holy days, further elaborated on this point. He asked me to translate those responsa which I felt it was important for our brethren to understand, but to do so "as a rebbe teaches a talmid." He asked that I work with meticulous care, presenting all the relevant background material in a lucid style, with full awareness that the readership would span the spectrum from Torah scholars to people with minimal background. He added, as an aside, that an English translation of the responsa would be available to non-Jews as well. Although teaching Torah to non-Jews is prohibited, our purpose in translating these responsa is to instruct Jews, and therefore we need not consider this translation a violation of the edict concerning the study of Torah by non-Jews.



                I have prepared the following translations in accordance with the above instructions. Although the English version is faithful to the original, I have included additional material, enclosed in brackets, to instruct and edify those who will turn to the writings of the greatest posek of our generation as to a personal rebbe.




                Portions of this book are available online at Google Books, and it is available on Sefaria as well.




                In Theology in the Responsa R. Louis Jacobs goes through each century of responsa literature and summarizes those responsa that relate to theology. In the section for the twentieth century he summarizes three of R. Feinstein's responsa. However, as far as I know this cannot be read online.






                share|improve this answer

























                  5












                  5








                  5







                  R. Feinstein's son in law R. Moshe Dovid Tendler published a translation/commentary of some of R. Feinstein's responsa relating to medical issues. The book is called Responsa of Rav Moshe Feinstein: Translation and Commentary Vol I Care of the Critically Ill. In his introduction R. Tendler discusses R. Feinsteins responsum (Y.D. 3:91) that prohibited the translation of his responsa, and R. Tendler cites a later responsum (Y.D. 4:38) to explain why his translation is okay. He also adds:




                  My great father-in-law, זצ"ל, in discussions at my home, where for decades he spent the Succos holy days, further elaborated on this point. He asked me to translate those responsa which I felt it was important for our brethren to understand, but to do so "as a rebbe teaches a talmid." He asked that I work with meticulous care, presenting all the relevant background material in a lucid style, with full awareness that the readership would span the spectrum from Torah scholars to people with minimal background. He added, as an aside, that an English translation of the responsa would be available to non-Jews as well. Although teaching Torah to non-Jews is prohibited, our purpose in translating these responsa is to instruct Jews, and therefore we need not consider this translation a violation of the edict concerning the study of Torah by non-Jews.



                  I have prepared the following translations in accordance with the above instructions. Although the English version is faithful to the original, I have included additional material, enclosed in brackets, to instruct and edify those who will turn to the writings of the greatest posek of our generation as to a personal rebbe.




                  Portions of this book are available online at Google Books, and it is available on Sefaria as well.




                  In Theology in the Responsa R. Louis Jacobs goes through each century of responsa literature and summarizes those responsa that relate to theology. In the section for the twentieth century he summarizes three of R. Feinstein's responsa. However, as far as I know this cannot be read online.






                  share|improve this answer













                  R. Feinstein's son in law R. Moshe Dovid Tendler published a translation/commentary of some of R. Feinstein's responsa relating to medical issues. The book is called Responsa of Rav Moshe Feinstein: Translation and Commentary Vol I Care of the Critically Ill. In his introduction R. Tendler discusses R. Feinsteins responsum (Y.D. 3:91) that prohibited the translation of his responsa, and R. Tendler cites a later responsum (Y.D. 4:38) to explain why his translation is okay. He also adds:




                  My great father-in-law, זצ"ל, in discussions at my home, where for decades he spent the Succos holy days, further elaborated on this point. He asked me to translate those responsa which I felt it was important for our brethren to understand, but to do so "as a rebbe teaches a talmid." He asked that I work with meticulous care, presenting all the relevant background material in a lucid style, with full awareness that the readership would span the spectrum from Torah scholars to people with minimal background. He added, as an aside, that an English translation of the responsa would be available to non-Jews as well. Although teaching Torah to non-Jews is prohibited, our purpose in translating these responsa is to instruct Jews, and therefore we need not consider this translation a violation of the edict concerning the study of Torah by non-Jews.



                  I have prepared the following translations in accordance with the above instructions. Although the English version is faithful to the original, I have included additional material, enclosed in brackets, to instruct and edify those who will turn to the writings of the greatest posek of our generation as to a personal rebbe.




                  Portions of this book are available online at Google Books, and it is available on Sefaria as well.




                  In Theology in the Responsa R. Louis Jacobs goes through each century of responsa literature and summarizes those responsa that relate to theology. In the section for the twentieth century he summarizes three of R. Feinstein's responsa. However, as far as I know this cannot be read online.







                  share|improve this answer












                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer










                  answered 2 days ago









                  AlexAlex

                  23.3k156133




                  23.3k156133













                      Popular posts from this blog

                      Àrd-bhaile Cathair chruinne/Baile mòr cruinne | Artagailean ceangailte | Clàr-taice na seòladaireachd

                      대한민국 목차 국명 지리 역사 정치 국방 경제 사회 문화 국제 순위 관련 항목 각주 외부 링크 둘러보기 메뉴북위 37° 34′ 08″ 동경 126° 58′ 36″ / 북위 37.568889° 동경 126.976667°  / 37.568889; 126.976667ehThe Korean Repository문단을 편집문단을 편집추가해Clarkson PLC 사Report for Selected Countries and Subjects-Korea“Human Development Index and its components: P.198”“http://www.law.go.kr/%EB%B2%95%EB%A0%B9/%EB%8C%80%ED%95%9C%EB%AF%BC%EA%B5%AD%EA%B5%AD%EA%B8%B0%EB%B2%95”"한국은 국제법상 한반도 유일 합법정부 아니다" - 오마이뉴스 모바일Report for Selected Countries and Subjects: South Korea격동의 역사와 함께한 조선일보 90년 : 조선일보 인수해 혁신시킨 신석우, 임시정부 때는 '대한민국' 국호(國號) 정해《우리가 몰랐던 우리 역사: 나라 이름의 비밀을 찾아가는 역사 여행》“남북 공식호칭 ‘남한’‘북한’으로 쓴다”“Corea 대 Korea, 누가 이긴 거야?”국내기후자료 - 한국[김대중 前 대통령 서거] 과감한 구조개혁 'DJ노믹스'로 최단기간 환란극복 :: 네이버 뉴스“이라크 "韓-쿠르드 유전개발 MOU 승인 안해"(종합)”“해외 우리국민 추방사례 43%가 일본”차기전차 K2'흑표'의 세계 최고 전력 분석, 쿠키뉴스 엄기영, 2007-03-02두산인프라, 헬기잡는 장갑차 'K21'...내년부터 공급, 고뉴스 이대준, 2008-10-30과거 내용 찾기mk 뉴스 - 구매력 기준으로 보면 한국 1인당 소득 3만弗과거 내용 찾기"The N-11: More Than an Acronym"Archived조선일보 최우석, 2008-11-01Global 500 2008: Countries - South Korea“몇년째 '시한폭탄'... 가계부채, 올해는 터질까”가구당 부채 5000만원 처음 넘어서“‘빚’으로 내몰리는 사회.. 위기의 가계대출”“[경제365] 공공부문 부채 급증…800조 육박”“"소득 양극화 다소 완화...불평등은 여전"”“공정사회·공생발전 한참 멀었네”iSuppli,08年2QのDRAMシェア・ランキングを発表(08/8/11)South Korea dominates shipbuilding industry | Stock Market News & Stocks to Watch from StraightStocks한국 자동차 생산, 3년 연속 세계 5위자동차수출 '현대-삼성 웃고 기아-대우-쌍용은 울고' 과거 내용 찾기동반성장위 창립 1주년 맞아Archived"중기적합 3개업종 합의 무시한 채 선정"李대통령, 사업 무분별 확장 소상공인 생계 위협 질타삼성-LG, 서민업종인 빵·분식사업 잇따라 철수상생은 뒷전…SSM ‘몸집 불리기’ 혈안Archived“경부고속도에 '아시안하이웨이' 표지판”'철의 실크로드' 앞서 '말(言)의 실크로드'부터, 프레시안 정창현, 2008-10-01“'서울 지하철은 안전한가?'”“서울시 “올해 안에 모든 지하철역 스크린도어 설치””“부산지하철 1,2호선 승강장 안전펜스 설치 완료”“전교조, 정부 노조 통계서 처음 빠져”“[Weekly BIZ] 도요타 '제로 이사회'가 리콜 사태 불러들였다”“S Korea slams high tuition costs”““정치가 여론 양극화 부채질… 합리주의 절실””“〈"`촛불집회'는 민주주의의 질적 변화 상징"〉”““촛불집회가 민주주의 왜곡 초래””“국민 65%, "한국 노사관계 대립적"”“한국 국가경쟁력 27위‥노사관계 '꼴찌'”“제대로 형성되지 않은 대한민국 이념지형”“[신년기획-갈등의 시대] 갈등지수 OECD 4위…사회적 손실 GDP 27% 무려 300조”“2012 총선-대선의 키워드는 '국민과 소통'”“한국 삶의 질 27위, 2000년과 2008년 연속 하위권 머물러”“[해피 코리아] 행복점수 68점…해외 평가선 '낙제점'”“한국 어린이·청소년 행복지수 3년 연속 OECD ‘꼴찌’”“한국 이혼율 OECD중 8위”“[통계청] 한국 이혼율 OECD 4위”“오피니언 [이렇게 생각한다] `부부의 날` 에 돌아본 이혼율 1위 한국”“Suicide Rates by Country, Global Health Observatory Data Repository.”“1. 또 다른 차별”“오피니언 [편집자에게] '왕따'와 '패거리 정치' 심리는 닮은꼴”“[미래한국리포트] 무한경쟁에 빠진 대한민국”“대학생 98% "외모가 경쟁력이라는 말 동의"”“특급호텔 웨딩·200만원대 유모차… "남보다 더…" 호화病, 고질병 됐다”“[스트레스 공화국] ① 경쟁사회, 스트레스 쌓인다”““매일 30여명 자살 한국, 의사보다 무속인에…””“"자살 부르는 '우울증', 환자 중 85% 치료 안 받아"”“정신병원을 가다”“대한민국도 ‘묻지마 범죄’,안전지대 아니다”“유엔 "학생 '성적 지향'에 따른 차별 금지하라"”“유엔아동권리위원회 보고서 및 번역본 원문”“고졸 성공스토리 담은 '제빵왕 김탁구' 드라마 나온다”“‘빛 좋은 개살구’ 고졸 취업…실습 대신 착취”원본 문서“정신건강, 사회적 편견부터 고쳐드립니다”‘소통’과 ‘행복’에 목 마른 사회가 잠들어 있던 ‘심리학’ 깨웠다“[포토] 사유리-곽금주 교수의 유쾌한 심리상담”“"올해 한국인 평균 영화관람횟수 세계 1위"(종합)”“[게임연중기획] 게임은 문화다-여가활동 1순위 게임”“영화속 ‘영어 지상주의’ …“왠지 씁쓸한데””“2월 `신문 부수 인증기관` 지정..방송법 후속작업”“무료신문 성장동력 ‘차별성’과 ‘갈등해소’”대한민국 국회 법률지식정보시스템"Pew Research Center's Religion & Public Life Project: South Korea"“amp;vwcd=MT_ZTITLE&path=인구·가구%20>%20인구총조사%20>%20인구부문%20>%20 총조사인구(2005)%20>%20전수부문&oper_YN=Y&item=&keyword=종교별%20인구& amp;lang_mode=kor&list_id= 2005년 통계청 인구 총조사”원본 문서“한국인이 좋아하는 취미와 운동 (2004-2009)”“한국인이 좋아하는 취미와 운동 (2004-2014)”Archived“한국, `부분적 언론자유국' 강등〈프리덤하우스〉”“국경없는기자회 "한국, 인터넷감시 대상국"”“한국, 조선산업 1위 유지(S. Korea Stays Top Shipbuilding Nation) RZD-Partner Portal”원본 문서“한국, 4년 만에 ‘선박건조 1위’”“옛 마산시,인터넷속도 세계 1위”“"한국 초고속 인터넷망 세계1위"”“인터넷·휴대폰 요금, 외국보다 훨씬 비싸”“한국 관세행정 6년 연속 세계 '1위'”“한국 교통사고 사망자 수 OECD 회원국 중 2위”“결핵 후진국' 한국, 환자가 급증한 이유는”“수술은 신중해야… 자칫하면 생명 위협”대한민국분류대한민국의 지도대한민국 정부대표 다국어포털대한민국 전자정부대한민국 국회한국방송공사about korea and information korea브리태니커 백과사전(한국편)론리플래닛의 정보(한국편)CIA의 세계 정보(한국편)마리암 부디아 (Mariam Budia),『한국: 하늘이 내린 한 폭의 그림』, 서울: 트랜스라틴 19호 (2012년 3월)대한민국ehehehehehehehehehehehehehehWorldCat132441370n791268020000 0001 2308 81034078029-6026373548cb11863345f(데이터)00573706ge128495

                      Cannot Extend partition with GParted The 2019 Stack Overflow Developer Survey Results Are In Announcing the arrival of Valued Associate #679: Cesar Manara Planned maintenance scheduled April 17/18, 2019 at 00:00UTC (8:00pm US/Eastern) 2019 Community Moderator Election ResultsCan't increase partition size with GParted?GParted doesn't recognize the unallocated space after my current partitionWhat is the best way to add unallocated space located before to Ubuntu 12.04 partition with GParted live?I can't figure out how to extend my Arch home partition into free spaceGparted Linux Mint 18.1 issueTrying to extend but swap partition is showing as Unknown in Gparted, shows proper from fdiskRearrange partitions in gparted to extend a partitionUnable to extend partition even though unallocated space is next to it using GPartedAllocate free space to root partitiongparted: how to merge unallocated space with a partition